Debate Judge Paradigms Wiki

Experienced debate judges who were generally debaters in high school and or college generally carry a mindset that favors certain arguments and styles over others.

Debate judge paradigms wiki. Join the national speech debate association about help contact. In debate judges consider or score the debate and ultimately vote for the winner of the debate round on a ballot. Debate is a popular extracurricular activity that gives participants opportunities to refine their critical thinking and public speaking skills. A judge may say that they are tabula rasa or willing to listen to anything but draw the line at arguments they consider to be offensive.

And i have debate two days a. The purpose of the ballot is what the judge s vote stands for or is intended to affirm. Judging debate tournaments is a great way to support this tradition. Part of the series policy debate organization policy debate competitions inter collegiate policy debate format structure of policy debate resolution constructive rebu.

Depending on what mindset or paradigm the judge uses the debate can be drastically different. How to judge a debate. Search for a judge at right to read paradigms. This template can be adapted for any tournament and also can be used by judges in recording their philosophy on the wiki template can be adapted for any tournament and also can be used by judges in recording their philosophy on the wiki.

In the structure of scientific revolutions kuhn wrote that the successive transition from one paradigm to another via revolution is the usual developmental pattern of mature science p. High school policy judge paradigms. For example a team might say the role of the ballot is to vote for whomever saves more lives in third world countries. Posted by 2 years ago.

Paradigm shifts tend to appear in response to the accumulation of critical anomalies as well as the proposal of a new theory with the power to encompass both older relevant data and explain relevant. Or a judge might be a policymaker but still look at the debate in an offense defense framework like a games playing judge. 2017 judge paradigms policy debate cx and lincoln douglas debate ld judge paradigms are now available for the 2017 national speech debate tournament. Not every judge fits perfectly into one paradigm or another.