Debate Judge Comments Sample

Download a sample comment sheet for policy debate.

Debate judge comments sample. Demand for the appropriate documents prior to the debate. If you want to judge a debate fairly don t let your opinions affect how you perceive the debate but use the criteria on the ballot to judge how well the participants made their case. Keep in mind that in every debate the only opinion that matters is the opinion of the judge and definitely not yours. Put yourself in the shoes of the judge listen to your opinion and ask yourself some questions that would help you improve your argument.

In a team there are at least 3 speakers and a representative who is often the last one to speak to present a summary of the points that were being made earlier at the end of the debate round. Use this sheet to learn how to judge lincoln douglas ld. In some debate formats this can be also called a motion and the sides will be proposition and opposition. 3 minutes responsibilities of the judge how to judge a debate judging is hard work.

However with these tips in mind you will ease your way to judging the debate effectively. Pay attention to the debate s rules as well and record the violations as they occur so you can score them properly. Tips for debate evaluations. Writing comments on the ballot during a debate obviously requires a bit of effort on the part of judges.

To be chosen as a judge for a debate is an interesting yet tough task to accomplish since debates can come on varying topics. Be the judge of your own opinion or argument. Judge ethically make a decision based upon the debate you hear o not their coach o not whether you like the debaters o not what happened last time this team met your team o not whether it might help your team treat students with respect odon t misuse your authority to berate students odon t use profanity or abusive language. The opportunity to read the comments that a judge has provided as they were experiencing the debate can help coaches better prepare their students to debate in front of that individual in the future.

Shows how given the arguments advanced in the debate the proposition wins the debate. 3 minutes proposition rebuttal refutes the arguments advanced and extended by the opposition side.